Advertorial
I Spent $174 On Slippers That Wouldn't Stay On. Here's The Pair I Should've Bought First.

Works from home · runs cold · two flights of stairs
Four pairs, two winters. Every one ended the same way: one step below my foot, on the stairs.
Here's what each pair got wrong, so you can skip to the one that didn't.
Pair 1: The $19 Drugstore Slides
Soft for about three weeks. Then the fluff went flat where my toes rubbed, and I could feel the floor through the sole.
One band over the toes, nothing behind it. On every stair, I gripped with my toes to keep them on.
Pair 2: The $38 Knit Booties
Closed all around, so they couldn't fall off. Problem solved, I thought.
Then I stepped out for a package on a wet morning. The soft sole soaked through in two steps. I spent the morning in damp socks.
Pair 3: The $48 Fleece Moccasins
Warm. Very warm. Too warm for a house with the heat on.
By 8 p.m. my feet were sweating and the moccasins were under the couch. A slipper you kick off isn't doing its job.
Pair 4: The $69 Boutique Slides
The pretty ones. Thick and curly, the kind you leave out when guests come.
Still one band. Carrying laundry down, the heel slid off on the third step. I nearly went down with the basket.
My Slipper Receipt
Two winters. Four pairs. Not one I'd buy again.
Rachel's slipper drawer
Two winters of trying
- 01Drugstore slides✕ Flat in three weeks$19
- 02Knit booties✕ Soaked on the porch$38
- 03Fleece moccasins✕ Too hot to keep on$48
- 04Boutique slides✕ Slid off on the stairs$69
None stayed on
Each pair fixed one problem and made another. Open meant falling off. Closed meant hot feet. Soft meant soggy.
Then I Watched My Sister Take The Stairs.
Over the holidays, she came down with a coffee in each hand. Her slippers didn't move.
Two plush straps: one over the toes, one over the instep. It holds your foot the way a sandal does, so it stays on with your hands full. Open at the toe, so it's warm feet, not sweaty ones.
The New York Slipper. She'd gotten the second pair free.
What Each Pair Got Wrong, Side By Side
New York Slipper
One-band slide
Closed moccasin
Only one column checks every line. The second strap fixes what one band can't. The open toe fixes what a closed slipper can't.
What Changed The First Week
I'd have bet an open toe was wrong for January. Then I stopped thinking about my feet at all.
- Down the stairs with coffee in one hand
- Laundry basket, both slippers still on
- Out to the porch for a package and back
- Still on at 10 p.m., not under the couch
Same pair, morning to night.
How Many Pairs Did Last Winter Cost You?
Slide to your number. Be honest. I wasn't, until I counted mine.
Right now, one order of the New York Slipper is two pairs: buy one, get one free. One by your bed, one for whoever keeps borrowing yours.
Two pairs, one order.
Your First Weeks In Them
Here's how mine went.
- Day 1Out of the package and on your feet, standing up, no hands.
- First cold morningDown the stairs with the coffee. Both still on at the bottom.
- The holidaysThe free pair goes to your sister, or waits by the guest bed.
- FebruaryStill the pair by your bed.
Made It This Far? Get The Pair That Stays On.
The New York Slipper, in Coffee, Cream, Black or Gray.
The New York Slipper
Two plush straps, an open toe and a textured sole that sits low to the ground.
Sizes come in pairs, like 7–8. Between two, take the larger.
Buy one pair, the second is free. The free pair won't be there forever.
- Buy 1, get 1 free
- 30 days to exchange
- Sizes 5–6 to 11–12



